Who owns the marketing plan my fractional CMO writes?
Why the copyright in a plan written by an outside marketing leader starts with the person who wrote it, why "work made for hire" rarely fixes that for a contractor, and the written assignment that does.
Unless your agreement says otherwise in writing, the fractional CMO usually does. The U.S. Copyright Office says copyright starts with the person who created the work, and a contractor's work becomes the client's automatically only in narrow cases that a marketing plan rarely fits. A signed assignment of the copyright to your company is the clean way to make the plan yours.
## Where copyright starts
Circular 1 says copyright exists from the moment an original work is fixed, such as typed into a document, and that it initially belongs to the author who created it. It also says owning a copy does not give you the copyright. Paying for a strategy deck and having the file on your drive does not, on its own, make you the owner of the words and structure in it.
## Why "work made for hire" usually does not help
Circular 30 describes two ways a work is made for hire, and in both the hiring party becomes the author and owner from the start.
The first is work an employee creates as part of the job. A fractional CMO is usually a contractor. The Copyright Office says courts decide who is an employee using common-law agency factors from the Supreme Court's decision in Community for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid: the skill involved, who supplies the tools and workspace, how long the relationship runs, whether the hiring party controls when and how long the person works, how they are paid, whether benefits and tax withholding apply, and whether the person runs their own business. A senior marketer working a few days a month through their own company tends to look like a contractor on most of these.
The second is a commissioned work that falls into one of nine categories, with a written agreement signed by both sides that says it is a work made for hire. The categories are a contribution to a collective work, part of a motion picture or other audiovisual work, a translation, a supplementary work, a compilation, an instructional text, a test, answer material for a test, and an atlas. A marketing strategy, positioning statement or campaign plan is not on that list, so writing "work made for hire" into the contract may not do what you expect.
## What does work
Circular 1 says a transfer of copyright generally must be in writing and signed by the owner of the rights, or the owner's authorized agent. So the agreement with your fractional CMO should include an assignment: the CMO assigns to your company the copyright in the plans, documents and materials created for you, signed by the CMO. Many contracts include both a work-made-for-hire clause and an assignment as a backstop.
Two details are worth settling at the same time. Experienced marketers bring templates and frameworks they used before you, and they will want to keep those. A reasonable contract lets them keep their own pre-existing tools while you own what was made for your company, with a license to use anything of theirs that ends up inside your materials. And Circular 1 notes that a nonexclusive permission does not need to be in writing, which is one more reason to write down exactly who owns what.
This is general information from the Copyright Office's circulars. A business lawyer can draft the clause for your situation.
## Before the contract
If you are still deciding whether a fractional CMO is the right hire, the four-minute diagnostic on this site scores whether your company needs one or should buy something else first.